Books: Berserk #25

| | Comments (4)

Let’s skip ahead a bit, shall we?

The last review I wrote of Berserk feels like ages ago, and while I was planning on going through the whole series in order before arriving at the most recent volumes, I had a nasty run-in with this thing called real life. Then volume 25 hit my doorstep, and I decided to save us all a lot of trouble and jump ahead. I should say that if you’ve any kind of investment in being surprised by the way Berserk unfolds and you haven’t gotten anywhere near this far, go back and get caught up. I hate to ruin a perfectly good surprise.

Volume 25 takes place in the main line of Berserk’s plotting — where Guts is a hulking engine of destruction, Casca a mute shell of a woman, and the world around them is being torn to pieces by demonic incursion. This installment kicks off in the middle of deep trouble, where Guts and his companions have stopped to aid a village being overrun by trolls. Guts’s sword, impressive as it is, only goes so far, and so a local magician — a lithe young girl named Schierke — steps in to lend a hand. Her use of sorcery sparks the ire of the local priest (“Blasphemy!” he thunders), but the townspeople could care less about blasphemy when their village is being overrun.

It takes the combined efforts of Guts, Schierke, and two others who are protecting Casca — the penant Lady Farnese and the smug Serpico — to protect the town not only from trolls, but a massive ogre (Guillermo del Toro would have a ball putting this monster on the screen!) and a “kelpie”, a supernatural monster spawned from the spirit of a drowned horse. All of this unfolds with the usual dollops of violence and mayhem that fans of the series have come to expect: barely a volume of Berserk has gone by without Guts ripping through a whole legion of monsters in one blow with that monster sword of his.

Two things come to light over the course of the volume. The first is something that’s been clear for a good long time, but illuminated in a new way in this installment: how Guts respects strength in others. Schierke may not be physically strong, but commands power that Guts can only guess at — and who’s he to turn down that kind of power when it’ll only help him? The other, and far more important thing, is how Schierke’s magic ties into the primal forces that drive the Berserk universe — forces thrown out of balance by the Godhand, and by Griffith’s alliance with them. The cosmology Miura created for this world is one of the most hotly debated things about it, mainly because so little of it is revealed at any one time — and the more we learn about it, the larger and more compelling Miura’s universe becomes. A smart strategy.

The volume concludes on as grotesque a cliffhanger as any that have come in the series: Casca and Farnese, cornered in a remote nook of the trolls’ lair, with fates worse than death staring them in the face. That’s as it should be: a volume of Berserk without a cliffhanger would be like glycerine without the nitro.


© Kentaro Miura
A little magic helps put a stop to a troll invasion.

Art: One constant point of praise for Berserk is Kentaro Miura’s artwork, and even though the first volumes are a little rougher and less polished than the later ones, you can immediately see what the screaming is about. By this point in the series, the art's plateaued — it's polished and consistent in every respect, to the point where not only does every page look fantastic but there’s scarcely a single frame that doesn’t have something truly eye-catching about it. Miura does more with the weight of his lines than most other artist do with the whole of a drawing. His loving attention to detail on most any page or panel is stupefying — and sometimes downright repulsive, as when he shows Guts spattering his namesake across the page. He also pays great attention to other kinds of details that matter — the look on a face, the knotted muscles in one’s shoulders or neck — and his character designs are markedly more “Western” (and that much more striking) than what you’d see in most other fantasy manga. It’s the sort of design work that’s impossible to mistake for anyone else’s achievements.

Translation: Dark Horse has almost never done a bad job with any of their titles. Berserk has been presented unflopped and uncensored (each volume is also in shrinkwrap, this being an 18+ title), although only spoken texts have been relettered. Sound effects are now being translated, with annotations for same done in an unobtrusive on-the-page format. This was one of my nitpicks for this particular series for some time, since earlier volumes left effects completely untranslated.

The Bottom Line: Even if this is ultimately a transitional or interstitial volume for the series — i.e., it’s designed to get us from one plot point to another, without too much else along the way — Miura’s gifted enough that he can make something that obligatory into a gripping experience. You’ll be best served by starting the series from the beginning, of course.



Article originally written for AMN.

Man, I couldn't disagree with you more on this. This is the one where the kid grabs the witch girl's breasts and she makes him act like a monkey, right? And the one where everyone gets elemental super-weapons, right? And the Godhands become these sort of elemental creatures, in a move strikingly reminiscent of the way August Derleth defanged Lovecraft's creations?

Sure, it's still disturbingly violent, but now it's descended into standard anime-style wackiness in an almost shockingly anodyne (given how the series used to be) setting. This series was special for a while, but now I have become thoroughly disillusioned.

[Reply to this comment]

I haven't seen any of that yet -- it might well have been in a volume that was before the jump I made. Then again, I have a higher threshold of tolerance for that kind of thing. To me, it would take a betrayal on the order of "oh, it was all a DREAM!" for me to call it quits on this series.

[Reply to this comment]

I don't know at what point you bailed, but if you missed it, you really must go back and read the story arc with the carnivorous fairies, which is gorgeous and heartbreaking.

That said, although I initially wanted to kill myself after being left hanging by the anime, in retrospect, I think it's better than the manga because, unresolved though it is, it captures the part of the manga that represents a dramatic, sustained, and above all focused narrative that shows Miura at his strongest without revealing his fallibility.

It's not that I would mind silly cliches and standard fantasy tropes in any other context, but it's clear at this point that he's more or less abandoned the nihilistic, Lovecraftian worldview that, for me, made the series so compelling. That represents a huge disappointment to me, especially since at this point it's painfully apparent that this thing is just going to go ON and ON and ON, meandering aimlessly through extended battle after battle after battle. I know this sounds a little harsh, but for me, the series has degenerated into a slightly more upscale Dragon Ball Z. That makes me sad. I don't know.

And I know I'm babbling on like a crazy person, but when I think back to how utterly captivated I was by this series at one point, it inspires strong emotions in me.

[Reply to this comment]

I can understand where you're coming from, believe me. I did have to jump ahead for the sake of getting caught up with the most recent releases, but I'm going to be doubling back and checking out what's in the gap I leaped over. From what I've seen, though, the "DBZ"-ness that you're citing doesn't look *quite* that bad, really. (I speak as someone who's seen much worse -- there's always a comparison to be made in that department!)

[Reply to this comment]

Leave a comment


Warning: Do not press "Preview" if you are replying to someone else's post. This will cause your message to be posted as a reply to the article itself.

Follow Me...

Subscribe  to feed Subscribe to this blog's feed

Follow me on Twitter

Friend me on Facebook

Friend me on Flickr

Also on LiveJournal

Read my stuff on
Profile

Twitter Updates

    [ Fetching ]

Monthly Archives

Powered by Movable Type 5.11
Bookmark and Share
Purchases benefit this site.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Serdar in the category External Book Reviews, published on December 21, 2008 1:54 PM.

» See other External Book Reviews entries for the month of December 2008.

» See all other entries for the month of December 2008.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Books I’ve Written


Tokyo Inferno

Evil stalks the streets of Tokyo, 1923, and will not rest until vengeance is found. Read a preview (PDF)  or buy a copy now! ($12 paperback / $20 signed)


The Four-Day Weekend

The “otaku novel”—about two guys who try to get away from it all, and end up taking it with them. Read a preview (PDF) or buy a copy now! ($12 paperback / $20 signed)


Summerworld

Fantasy meets psychology. A story of high adventure and deep insight in a place where desire reshapes the face of the world. Read a preview (PDF) or buy a copy now! ($12 paperback / $20 signed)

More of my writing.