Brain Drain Dept.

| | Comments (2)

Some nice comments from an author of children's books about taking Sundays off.

Sunday Routine - Rebecca Stead - For Rebecca Stead, a Day to Recharge the Brain’s Batteries - NYTimes.com

On another note, there's book designer Craig Mod, with this discussion of "books in the age of the iPad": Print is dying. Digital is surging. Everyone is confused. Good riddance.

He makes a case for the "canvas" being what's changing: it's not that books themselves are dying, just that the most disposable versions of books are being phased out in favor of digital devices. Books where the canvas of paper is indispensible — e.g., graphic novels, art books — will continue to exist, although at premium prices. Books that are "just text" will simply move to another, more malleable and portable container.

In short, we're seeing another iteration of what happened with books back when cheap paperbacks entered the market and created a priced-down alternative to hardbacks. This didn't phase out hardbacks entirely, though; I've written elsewhere about why hardbacks continue to be important to publishing. (Early access, collectible form factor.)

I'm still iffy on dedicated reading devices, if only because I dislike the idea of throwing hundreds of dollars at something that essentially duplicates most of the functionality of something I already have. The Kindle is twice as redundant now that there's a Kindle app for the PC, which I can install on any machine that has a net connection. Yes, I don't get the (dubious) comfort of reading on the Kindle device itself, but at least I have access to all the same content — and by Craig's own admission, that's what really counts here.

Previous | Next

Bill McD

I dunno... I find electronic formats to be far more transient, disposable, and well, ephemeral than books. Books exist, as a physical object, and just handling them can get the mind going. Scrolling through a document or a pdf or a webpage isn't the same at all, and I've yet to see anything that makes me think it ever will be.

And, should the 'unthinkable' happen, books will continue to exist. If we are (as we so often seem to be intent on proving ourselves to be) so short-sighted and nihilistic that we bury our heads in the sand on the issues of climatic shift, with all of the attendant geopolitical instability it will cause should we ignore it... then infrastructures will be horribly damaged. Books exist. Where are the 1s and 0s when the power grid's down? How many e-books get read in a blackout?

Books exist, and can be read without anything but you, and the book. e-books will never have that, by their very nature. Nor are they intended to last. They are meant to take up space until you are ready for the next book, and then they're gone, stored, as we've already seen from Amazon, only so long as the company you rent permission to read from wants it stored.

[Reply to this comment]

I agree with you about one of the virtues of a book being its relatively primitive design: all you need is your eyes and some light. Music (barring performance) always required some degree of electronic technology, but I think there's always going to be room for low-tech reading of one kind or another. Despite all that can go wrong with books -- acid in the paper, bad bindings -- they have a pretty stupefying level of durability at their best.

It also makes me think: if everything's gonna be on the Kindle in ten years, what am I going to autograph for people when they come to my booth?

[Reply to this comment]

Leave a comment


Warning: Do not press "Preview" if you are replying to someone else's post. This will cause your message to be posted as a reply to the article itself.

Follow Me...

Subscribe  to feed Subscribe to this blog's feed

Follow me on Twitter

Friend me on Facebook

Friend me on Flickr

Also on LiveJournal

Read my stuff on
Profile

Twitter Updates

    [ Fetching ]

Monthly Archives

Powered by Movable Type 5.11
Bookmark and Share

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Serdar, published on March 7, 2010 1:41 PM.

» See all other entries for the month of March 2010.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Books I’ve Written


Tokyo Inferno

Evil stalks the streets of Tokyo, 1923, and will not rest until vengeance is found. Read a preview (PDF)  or buy a copy now! ($12 paperback / $20 signed)


The Four-Day Weekend

The “otaku novel”—about two guys who try to get away from it all, and end up taking it with them. Read a preview (PDF) or buy a copy now! ($12 paperback / $20 signed)


Summerworld

Fantasy meets psychology. A story of high adventure and deep insight in a place where desire reshapes the face of the world. Read a preview (PDF) or buy a copy now! ($12 paperback / $20 signed)

More of my writing.